I am a big
fan of the American band, Wilco. I
happened to find a book written by the lead singer, Jeff Tweedy recently. It is called “How to Write One Song,” and it
was very inspiring. After reading the
book, I started writing a song on the guitar.
I haven’t written any songs for about 15 years, but it was interesting
to try Tweedy’s methods.
Here are a
few quotes from the book, and some of my thoughts about them.
1
“Don’t
undervalue things that come easy. Sometimes they’re the things that would be
the hardest for someone else to do and often they are the things that would be
almost impossible to do when you try too hard.”
I once
wrote a song in my sleep. When I was a
university student, I had a dream in which I was holding a guitar and singing a
song. I had a unique melody, and what
seemed at the time to be interesting lyrics.
Unfortunately,
I didn’t own a guitar, and I didn’t know how to play one yet. I had no recording device, either. So I went back to sleep and my song was lost.
Paul
McCartney famously wrote the song “Yesterday” in the same way. He wrote it in his dream. So maybe Jeff Tweedy is right: sometimes the
best things you create can come easily.
2
“No work of
art is ever finished; it can only be abandoned in an interesting place.”
Songs which
someone has tried hard to perfect can often be less interesting than the first
demo version of the same song. Somehow,
you can get a better sense of the warmth of the human musicians if you hear a
rough vocal or a sigh or laugh caught on the microphone. A good example of an imperfect but warm and
slightly wonky recording is Orange Juice’s version of the song, “L.O.V.E.”.
3
“I find
it’s almost impossible to put two words together and not find at least some
meaning. We’re conditioned to look for patterns and identify mysteries to solve
much more than we are designed to dictate what we’re searching for. I recommend
allowing that natural curiosity and our sense-making brains to do their thing.”
Tweedy
suggests playing with words, and finding random connections between them to
make unique lyrics. Obviously not all
random collections of words will be interesting, but you might be able to pick
out a few interesting combinations, and build a poem or song lyric around those
random combinations.
4
“So if
you’re doing something with your free time other than writing a song, it’s
because you really don’t want to write a song.”
Don’t
complain that you have no time to do something creative, and then sit down and
watch tv for two hours.
5
“Being
willing to sound bad is one of the most important pieces of advice that I can
give you. Writing a song will teach you that it’s OK to fail. And more than
that, that it’s actually good to fail, and that you can come to appreciate the
gifts of failure.”
The book
sounds a bit Buddhist at times: It’s not
the destination that counts, but the journey.
Tweedy is
convinced that doing something creative is good for your mental health. It can be writing haiku, drawing pictures, or
finding the beauty in an unusual sound.
Like God, we all have the power to create something that wasn’t there
before, even if it is only ourselves that appreciate the creation. And like a child we have created, our poem or
song doesn’t even have to be great in every way for us to love it.